BairesDev

SAST vs DAST: Where They Fit in a Modern Application Security Strategy

SAST scans code at rest; DAST tests live behavior. Learn how to deploy both without slowing your dev team down.

Last updated:
10 min read
Verified Top Talent

By Jimmy E. Bonilla

DevOps Engineer11 Years of Experience

Jimmy is a senior DevOps engineer with 10+ years of experience in automation and infrastructure optimization. He has delivered solutions for Walmart and held roles at Euronet Worldwide. Jimmy specializes in containerized orchestration and cloud deployments.

Abstract cybersecurity illustration representing SAST and DAST, featuring code analysis, security scanning, and a connected testing workflow for modern application security.

Key Points

  • SAST and DAST are testing methods for security testing using automated tools. Each works at different stages of the software development lifecycle and produces security evidence with different strengths, weaknesses and impacts on engineering costs and velocity.
  • SAST catches SQL injection and XSS in your source code before a single line ships to a test environment.
  • Dynamic Application Security Testing (DAST) is a form of black-box testing where application behavior is tested at runtime to identify security vulnerabilities in APIs, web services and user interfaces of web applications.
  • Targeted and thoughtful deployment of SAST and DAST tools can help development teams and security teams improve application security without compromising the development process or velocity.
  • BairesDev provides nearshore cybersecurity staffing with engineers experienced in SAST, DAST and other AppSec practices who integrate with your existing development process.

Quick Answer

SAST and DAST produce different kinds of security evidence. They are complementary testing methods that provide layers of prevention and detection. They are important parts of a comprehensive security strategy, but not sufficient on their own.

What Is Static Application Security Testing?

Static Application Security Testing is the use of tools to “analyze an application’s source, bytecode, or binary code for security vulnerabilities” [NIST]. It is considered a white box testing approach because it focuses on source code rather than running applications. It is also a form of static analysis, specifically static code analysis.

SAST tools are typically applied at the development stage of the software development life cycle. SAST can be used with integrated development environments (IDEs) to analyze code as it is being developed, or at compile time to block builds with critical vulnerabilities. Finally, it can be used as a quality gate in a continuous integration / continuous delivery (CI/CD) pipeline, at merge time or build time and prior to deployment.

SAST tools can detect coding patterns for SQL injection, buffer overflows, cross-site scripting (XSS), XML External Entity (XXE) injection, OWASP Top 10 violations, SANS/CWE Top 25 issues and others. If enforced in the IDE and build pipelines, SAST tools prevent such issues from entering the product in the first place. 

SAST aligns well with Shift Left Testing [link to BairesDev article], a testing approach that emphasizes early detection of issues by testing as early as possible in the software development lifecycle.

SAST tools have several weaknesses. By design, they cannot detect security issues that only occur at runtime, such as misconfiguration of servers. SAST tools tend to produce many false positives. Development teams risk being slowed down by the volume of these issues, or worse, become desensitized to them over time. These risks can be prevented by including development teams as partners with security teams on the rollout and tuning of SAST tools within the development process.

What Is Dynamic Application Security Testing (DAST)?

Dynamic Application Security Testing is a testing method that uses tools to “analyze applications in their dynamic, running state” [NIST] for security issues. It is considered a black box testing approach because it focuses on the running application rather than source code at rest.

DAST tools are typically used during testing and operational phases of the software development lifecycle. DAST tools should be included as a quality gate in the CI/CD pipeline after deployment of the code to a test environment, and before promotion of a build artifact to staging or production environments. DAST tools should also be run in staging or production to detect environment-specific security issues and deployment issues.

DAST tools simulate attacks against APIs, web services and user interfaces of applications, analyzing the application’s responses and runtime vulnerabilities that result. They can detect several types of issues that SAST cannot, including authentication issues, encryption issues and misconfiguration of servers.

A weakness of DAST tools is that they have no access to an application’s source code, and cannot help determine where in it the security flaw lies.

SAST vs DAST: Key Differences

The following comparison table breaks down the key differences between SAST and DAST. Both approaches try to identify vulnerabilities and security flaws, but do so in different ways and with different trade-offs.

SAST DAST
Testing approach Analyze an application’s source, bytecode or binary code at rest Analyze applications in their dynamic, running state
SDLC Stage Development Testing, Operations
Source code access Yes No
Runtime Requirements Developer Machine, No Deployment Required Test, Staging, or Production Environment, Deployment Required
Vulnerability Coverage SQL injection, Buffer overflows, Cross-site scripting (XSS), XML External Entity (XXE) injection, OWASP Top 10 and SANS/CWE Top 25 SQL injection, cross-site scripting (XSS), authentication issues, encryption issues and misconfiguration 
Feedback Speed Fast Slow
Ability to locate vulnerable code High. Inherently able to locate vulnerable code. Low. Dependent on logging and tracing to locate vulnerable code.
Credibility considerations High tendency for false positives. Tuning can reduce false positives, but care must be taken not to introduce false negatives.  Low tendency for false positives. Low tendency for false negatives.
CI/CD considerations Build stage. Quality gate for build, or immediately after build and prior to deployment. Testing stage. Post deployment. Quality gate for promotion of build artifacts to staging or production.
Ideal Use Cases New products, new teams, or those already using the shift left testing approach, unit testing, and code coverage tools. Organizations already using SAST, or organizations that already have system or acceptance testing environments.

In the next section, we’ll discuss considerations for adopting SAST and DAST in more detail, including how to think about SAST vs DAST when resources are limited.

Adopting SAST and DAST

As mentioned earlier, organizations should approach SAST and DAST as complementary approaches. Ideally, organizations should adopt both. But what if budget constraints mean you can only adopt one of them this year? Understanding SAST vs DAST trade-offs can help you decide which to put in place first.

Adoption of SAST and DAST should be considered in the context of existing development processes, the full development lifecycle, continuous integration and delivery pipelines, and functional testing approaches and environments. For example, development teams that already have unit testing, code coverage and build pipelines with quality gates will find SAST to fit well with those code quality practices. Similarly, organizations that already have system and acceptance testing environments and test pipelines that prevent release without high quality, will find it easier to adopt DAST tests than organizations without these entities in place.

We recommend adopting SAST first and DAST later in most cases, for the same reasons that unit tests should be put in place before system tests, or build pipelines put in place before test pipelines.

Selecting SAST and DAST Tools

A variety of open source and commercial tools are available for SAST and DAST. We highlight some of the key aspects to consider when selecting a tool.

First we’ll look at four SAST tools: Aikido SAST, Semgrep Code, SonarQube, and Veracode. For SAST tools, programming language support is a primary consideration. We also note whether the project is open source, commercial, or both.

Aikido SAST Semgrep Code SonarQube Veracode Static Analysis
Website https://www.aikido.dev/platform/code https://semgrep.dev/products/semgrep-code/ https://www.sonarsource.com/products/sonarqube/ https://www.veracode.com/products/binary-static-analysis-sast/
Types Commercial Open Source, Commercial Open Source, Commercial Commercial
Programming Languages Android, Apex, C#, C/C++, Clojure, Dart, Elixir, Go, Java, Javascript, Kotlin, PHP, Python, Ruby, Rust, Scala, Swift, Typescript and Visual Basic Apex, Bash, C, C++, C#, Clojure, Dart, Dockerfile, Elixir, HTML, Go, Java, JavaScript, JSX, JSON, Julia, Jsonnet, Kotlin, Lisp, Lua, OCaml, PHP, Python, R, Ruby, Rust, Scala, Scheme, Solidity, Swift, Terraform, TypeScript, TSX, YAML and XML ABAP, Ansible, Apex, Azure Pipelines, Azure Resource Manager, C, C++, CloudFormation, COBOL, C#, CSS, Dart, Docker, Flex, GitHub Actions, Go, Gosu, Groovy, HTML, Java, JavaScript, JCL, JSON, Kotlin, Kubernetes/Helm, Objective-C, PHP, PL/I, PL/SQL, Powershell, Python, RPG, Ruby, Rust, Scala, Secrets, Shell, Swift, Terraform, TypeScript, TSQL, VB.NET, VB6, XML and YAML .NET MAUI, ASP.NET, Android, Apex, Apple Platforms, C#, C++/CLI, C/C++ Linux Binaries, C/C++ Preprocessed Source, C/C++ Windows Binaries, COBOL, Classic ASP, ColdFusion, Dart & Flutter, Go, Groovy, Ionic, Java, JavaScript, Kotlin, PHP, PL/SQL, Perl, PhoneGap/Cordova, Python, RPG, React Native, Ruby on Rails, Scala, T-SQL, Titanium, TypeScript, VB.NET, Visual Basic 6 and Xamarin
Source Code https://github.com/AikidoSec https://github.com/semgrep/semgrep https://github.com/SonarSource/sonarqube https://github.com/veracode
Contributors 18 213 358 3
CI/CD Integrations Azure DevOps, Bitbucket Pipelines, GitHub Actions and GitLab CI Azure Pipelines, Bitbucket Pipelines, BuildKite, CircleCI, GitHub Actions, GitLab CI and Jenkins Azure Pipelines, Bitbucket Pipelines, CircleCI, GitHub Actions and Travis CI Atlassian Bamboo, AWS CodeStar, Azure DevOps, GitHub, GitLab, Jenkins and JetBrains TeamCity
AI Integrations Aikido MCP Plugin Semgrep MCP Server SonarQube MCP Server Veracode MCP (Third Party)

Next we’ll look at four DAST tools, including tools by Aikido, BlackDuck, Invicti, and Veracode.

Aikido DAST BlackDuck Continuous Dynamic Invicti DAST Veracode Dynamic Analysis
Website https://www.aikido.dev/platform/code https://www.aikido.dev/platform/code https://www.invicti.com/product/dast https://www.veracode.com/products/dynamic-analysis-dast/
CI/CD Integrations Azure DevOps, Bitbucket Pipelines, CircleCI, GitHub Actions, GitLab CI, Jenkins and TeamCity Data Not Available Azure Pipelines, GitHub Actions, GitLab CI/CD and Jenkins Azure Pipelines, GitHub Actions and Jenkins
AI Integrations Aikido MCP Plugin BlackDuck MCP Server Multiple AI Integrations Veracode MCP (Third Party)

Other Application Security Practices

SAST and DAST are just two of the practices for application security.

  • Manual Code Review by cybersecurity experts can identify security issues that SAST tools cannot, such as business logic errors, and complex vulnerabilities that emerge from interactions with other code.
  • Software Composition Analysis (SCA) is the use of tools to “identify open-source and third-party components in use in an application, their known security vulnerabilities, and typically adversarial license restrictions.” [NIST].
  • Interactive Application Security Testing (IAST) combines “elements of DAST with the instrumentation of the application under test” [NIST]. IAST addresses one of the weaknesses of DAST by improving the ability to locate the source code where a vulnerability exists.
  • Runtime Application Self Protection (RASP) uses runtime instrumentation to detect and block computer attacks by taking advantage of information from inside the running software.
  • Fuzzing is “a software testing technique that sends large volumes of malformed, unexpected, or random inputs to an application” [Invicti]. The goal of fuzzing is to “trigger abnormal behavior such as crashes, memory corruption, or unexpected system responses”. Unlike DAST which focuses on known attack vectors, fuzzing can detect unknown issues.
  • Penetration Testing involves simulating real-world cyberattacks by cybersecurity experts, allowing organizations to better prepare their systems and mitigate future risks. BairesDev offers Penetration Testing as part of its cybersecurity services.

A widely cited critical vulnerability, Heartbleed was undetected for two years until it was discovered independently using Manual Code Review and Fuzzing in the same week in 2014. Heartbleed shows the risk of relying exclusively on approaches like SAST and DAST that detect only known types of vulnerabilities.

Key Takeaways

  • When considering whether to adopt SAST, DAST, or both to strengthen their security posture, leaders should consider the maturity of existing development practices and test environments. SAST benefits from shift left testing practices such as unit tests, code coverage, and build pipelines.
  • Periodic tuning of SAST and DAST tools is needed as application features grow over time to reduce false positives without increasing false negatives. If analysis identifies more potential vulnerabilities than development teams have time to analyze, prioritization frameworks should be applied.
  • SAST and DAST together should be only part of an organization’s comprehensive application security strategy, which should include developer training in security best practices, other AppSec practices, security controls and security monitoring for the organization’s testing, staging and production environments.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What is SAST?

    SAST tools analyze source code for vulnerabilities such as SQL injection and XSS before code reaches a test environment. SAST tools are typically applied at the development stage of the software development life cycle.

  • What is DAST?

    Dynamic Application Security Testing (DAST) is a form of black-box testing where application behavior is tested at runtime to identify security vulnerabilities in APIs, web services and user interfaces of web applications. DAST tools are typically applied at the testing and operations stages of the software development life cycle.

  • Which should I use first, SAST or DAST?

    Start with SAST. If your team already has unit tests, code coverage and a build pipeline, SAST slots in naturally as another quality gate at build time. DAST needs a deployed environment to run against, so it requires more infrastructure to be in place first. The sequencing mirrors why you’d set up unit tests before system tests or build pipelines before test pipelines.

  • Are SAST and DAST sufficient for application security?

    No. There are many security practices that can identify vulnerabilities that SAST and DAST cannot, including Manual Code Review, Software Composition Analysis (SCA), Interactive Application Security Testing (IAST), Runtime Application Self Protection (RASP), Fuzzing and Penetration Testing. BairesDev has cybersecurity experts with experience in many of these techniques as well as SAST, DAST, and others.

By Jimmy E. Bonilla

DevOps Engineer11 Years of Experience

Jimmy is a senior DevOps engineer with 10+ years of experience in automation and infrastructure optimization. He has delivered solutions for Walmart and held roles at Euronet Worldwide. Jimmy specializes in containerized orchestration and cloud deployments.